Showing posts with label Luther. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Luther. Show all posts

Thursday, August 12, 2010

Trueman (Quoting Luther) on Being a Theologian

`A doctor of the Scriptures ought to have a good knowledge of the Scriptures and ought to have grasped how the prophets run into one another. It isn't enough to know only one part -- as a man might know Isaiah, for example -- or to know only one topic of the law or of the gospel. Now, however, doctors are springing up who scarcely have a right comprehension of one topic.

`Teachers of law can humble their students when the students try to put on airs about their learning, because they have a court and get practical experience. On the other hand, we can't humble our students because we have no practical exercises. Yet experience alone makes a theologian.'

Set in context, Luther's statement is clearly about those who whose task it is to study the scriptures, i.e., theologians; and his concern is to underscore the need for practical, personal engagement with the word of God. Thus, the experience that makes a theologians cannot be reduced to pure subjectivity: it is experience of the external word of God impacting upon the individual. Further, he is using `experience' here to refer to such work of the word in actual, practical, real-life settings, presumably and primarily pastoral contexts but, given his notion of the priesthood of all believers (of which more tomorrow) by implication the work of the word on each and every believer in their daily lives. One might say that his comment here reflects the perennial concern of all involved in training pastors: classroom and library learning is not enough in and of itself; only real-life engagement with the word of God can someone truly a theologian in the church sense of the word.

Thus, the third mark of the theologian, experience, is really a reference to the experience of the individual of the word of God in the context of their everyday life. Further, to state the obvious, this experience is therefore based upon a text, indeed, a clearly defined and delimited text; but it is not overly narrow because of that -- rather, it is wide ranging, touching on all areas of human experience: the word touches human beings as whole human beings. The voices of the Psalmists are thus great examples of the theological development brought about by this experience: it involves joy, sadness, setbacks, disappointments, triumphs etc etc. And experience is definitely not to be set in opposition to scripture, as both pietists and intellectualists tend so to do, albeit from opposite ends of the spectrum. Experience is caused by, grounded in, and defined by scripture.

One final point: this kind of experience takes time. For Luther, the growth of the theologian is gradual; it is not the equivalent of learning a logarithm table or a set of facts; it is the slow process of being interpreted by -- in fact, mastered by -- the word of God. Further, the passive nature of experience -- that it is the external word of God working on us -- indicates that there are no shortcuts, no educational programs, no techniques -- in short, no actions, nothing we ourselves can do -- to make this happen for ourselves. It is the work of the word, acting upon us, gradually making us that which we should be, in and through the lives we live. though Luther does not put it in quite these terms, we might say that the human contribution to such is patience in both the common and the more technical sense of the word.

Monday, May 17, 2010

Mounce on Languages

First, Luther is very clear that there is a pragmatic need for learning the languages; it makes us more effective students, teachers, and preachers.



A simple preacher (it is true) has so many clear passages and texts available through translations that he can know and teach Christ, lead a holy life, and preach to others. But when it comes to interpreting Scripture, and working with it on your own, and disputing with those who cite it incorrectly, he is unequal to the task; that cannot be done without languages.



And, he continues with a fabulous statement about the importance of the languages for powerful preaching:



Therefore, although faith and the gospel may indeed be proclaimed by simple preachers without a knowledge of languages, such preaching is flat and tame; people finally become weary and bored with it, and it falls to the ground. But where the preacher is versed in the languages, there is a freshness and vigor in his preaching, Scripture is treated in its entirety, and faith finds itself constantly renewed by a continual variety of words and illustrations.



For Luther, then, we need to know the original languages because they add power to our messages, confidence to our ministries, depth to our arguments. And, those are no small matters. We should be able to handle the Word with confidence and proclaim with power. The time we have spent on the languages is a gift to our ministries and students.



But, as several of our commenters pointed out yesterday, there must be more. If understanding the languages is a purely pragmatic issue, then my best bet would be to find Greek and Hebrew scholars that I really trust and simply rely on their conclusions. It’s unlikely that I will ever spend more time on Greek and Hebrew than Bill Mounce or Miles van Pelt (since they actually wrote books on learning Greek and Hebrew). And, if I can’t really do better than they can, wouldn’t it be more efficient to use my time doing something else? Why not trust a good commentary and spend my time working on powerful illustrations and applications? This is precisely what a pragmatic approach to the languages would suggest.



So, I find it interesting that Luther’s main argument is not a pragmatic one. His starting point is the Gospel.



We will not long preserve the gospel without the languages. The languages are the sheath in which this sword of the Spirit is contained; they are the casket in which this jewel is enshrined; they are the vessel in which this wine is held; they are the larder in which this food is stored; and, as the gospel itself points out, they are the baskets in which are kept these loaves and fishes and fragments.



Luther’s fundamental concern is that if we do not pay particular and close attention to the text, we will lose the Gospel itself. Left to ourselves, we will inevitably fashion the Gospel in our own image, after our own preferences, according to our own desires. Although Luther regularly ascribes value to studying translations of the Bible, he argues that this is not ultimately sufficient. Unless we dig deeply into the text, we will eventually lose our moorings and drift into the stream of contemporary (ir)relevance.



Hence, it is inevitable that unless the languages remain, the gospel must finally perish.



So, we have now two reasons for studying the original languages: effective ministry and protection of the Gospel. To these, I think we must add a third: spiritual formation. I would agree with a comment that Ben made yesterday: “this is part of a spiritual journey not necessarily an educational one.” We must constantly remind ourselves that we are not studying the original languages; we are studying the Word of God. The languages are simply a means to that end. As Luther said, they are the “sheath.” So, I think we would do better to think of learning the languages as a spiritual discipline. It is an intentional practice designed to draw one toward a more intimate knowledge of God so that he/she can be continually re-shaped in his image. Only by constantly reminding ourselves that this is what we are doing, can we resist the alluring pull of pragmatism and the inevitable conclusion that we should just let someone else do it for us.